In February, I went to a fair trade conference. This makes me sound like I’m somewhat of an activist, but embarassingly, I’m so not. A girl in the department sent an email to the grad student listserve asking if anyone would be interested in trying to get fair trade coffee on campus. I wrote back — yes I would — and the next thing I knew I was on a plane to Chicago for the 2nd Annual United Students for Fair Trade conference. In February, no less.
Snow sucks. But my college friend Anne, who lives there, researched bars in the two-block radius around the hotel I was staying in — which took us — me, Anne, and Kelly, another college friend — to Manhattan’s. Not exactly the city’s hotspot, but we knew no one, and we happend to be there on karaoke night. Some rounds later and Anne runs up to the “stage” area when she hears a Stones tune — nevermind that girls we didn’t know had the mic — and gets about half way though before realizing that no, this isn’t the Stones. As for me — Anne introduced me to a guy she was dating at the time. Then when his friend introduced himself like five minutes later, I waved him off, saying yeah, you’re anne’s guy, already met you. Kinda embarassing, but in bars you don’t frequent, there are no consequences.
Except the hangovers. The next morning two USTF leaders bounced up and down on my bed singing a song in Spanish — all I remember are “avanti” and “socialismo” — in an effort to wake me up. I made it for the afternoon sessions.
But I still learned enough that weekend to get really, really depressed about the world, with its money issues — which instead of inciting me to action, made me feel really helpless. Someone described it to be like trying to take down a skyscraper with a toothpick. And now, CAFTA’s been passed in the Senate, while most of the US public doesn’t know what CAFTA is, and most of those who do — like myself — don’t know what we can do about it.
Part of the trouble is that local info — the info that makes you feel like you can do your little part — is really, really hard to find. Take The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf for instance. There’s one walking distance from me, so when I got back from the conference, I sent them this message:
Sent: Tuesday, February 22, 2005 12:46 PM
To: ! Comments
Subject: fair trade coffee
Dear Sir or Madam: I was wondering if your stores offer fair trade coffee. As a frequent Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf customer living near your headquarters in Los Angeles, I am concerned that the money I spend on my coffee may be contributing to international trade injustices. Please let me know. I look forward to hearing from you. Thanks, Siel.
This is what I got back (excerpt):
Good Morning Siel! Thank you so much for taking the time to contact us! I can greatly appreciate your concerns…. We currently do not provide any Fair Trade coffee; rather, we choose to foster long-term relationships with coffee growers directly…. We are able to pay a higher price for our coffee, far exceeding the current coffee prices.
Without providing exact numbers (because I don’t have them available), we typically pay twice per pound as the average coffee company…. We also enter into long term contracts and relationships to ensure that we are always purchasing the highest quality product and paying a fair price for the coffee we purchase….
Which boils down to: The Bean, though not fair trade, pays fairer wages for their coffee than, say, Nescafe. Which is very pretty-sounding, except we still don’t know how much The Bean’s growers are paid unless you make a concerted effort to find out (I’ll try calling them tomorrow to pin down an exact number), compared to the FT price guarantee of at least $1.26 per pound for growers.
I’m not saying The Bean’s horrible — In fact they seem nice, compared to a lot of other companies out there. They recycle, for one, as the largest U.S. company awarded Certified Green Restaurant status by The National Green Restaurant Association. I don’t want to be an anal coffee prude who snubs all coffee without my seal of choice — that seems terribly yuppie — but I also think FT does a lot of great things — both for coffee growers and for coffee consumers.
Bean? Or no Bean?
Update, 7/23/05: Chicago karaoke pics here.
Tags: fairtrade, chicago, usft